The big idea
Some religions were invented. That fact says nothing about any particular claim.
The statement is usually doing two jobs at once. It is a historical claim — religions were constructed by people — and a truth claim — therefore none of them are true. The first is partly right. The second does not follow from it.
This is the genetic fallacy: judging a belief by its origin rather than its content. Every belief anyone holds arrived through some process — upbringing, culture, argument, experience. If origin settled truth, we would have to discard atheism too, since it also comes to people through culture, books and social context.
The productive move is to narrow. "Religion" as a category cannot be evaluated; it includes contradictory systems. Christianity makes specific historical claims — a named man, a named governor, a public execution, a specific claim about what happened next. Those can be examined. Ask to examine them.
Key argument
Origin does not settle truth
- 1Every belief arrives through some causal process.
- 2The process by which a belief arrives is separate from whether it is true.
- 3Therefore "it was invented by people" is not itself an argument against a claim.
The objection
"But we can see exactly how religions get invented over time."
Best response
We can, and that history is worth taking seriously — it should make all of us more careful. But showing that some claims were constructed does not show that a given claim was. That still requires looking at the specific evidence, which is what I would rather do.
Mistake to avoid
Defending "religion" in general. You are not obligated to. Narrow to the specific claims you actually hold.
Conversation move
"I would not defend religion as a category either. Can we look at one specific claim instead — did Jesus rise?"
Memory line
"How you got a belief and whether it is true are two different questions."
Practice
Someone says all religions are invented. What is your first narrowing question?
Self-check
2 questions to check the idea stuck. This one is just for you — it is not scored and does not affect your quiz accuracy. The path quiz is the graded one.
Judging a belief by where it came from is called:
You should defend "religion" as a general category.
Sign in to mark lessons complete and keep private notes
Progress, flashcard scheduling and your readiness score are saved to your account.